Free articles
Google
Web www.articles4free.net

Home : :  Business   : : Submit Article : : Contact Us


Home equity loans and the business cycle 
Although consumer debt is at an all-time end, it will not necessarily act as restriction on future economic growth; factors such as demographics, convenience use of credit cards, deregulation of the financial services industry, and a new avenue of consumer credit - home equity loans - must be considered. The traditional government statistics on consumer installment credit do not include home equity loans; thus, the home equity portion of consumer debt must be estimated. It is not clear how this small but rapidly growing portion of total consumer debt will reach to changes in the business cycle. Both of these issues are addressed in an effort to estimate the size of this consumer lending segment and to predict its influence.

HOME EQUITY LOANS, the fastest-growing form of consumer credit today, are a new factor affecting the interpretation of all measures of consumer debt. This growth reflects the impact of the Tax Reform Act of 1986, which eliminated the interest cost deduction for consumer installment debt but retained it for some home mortgage loan interest. To measure accurately total consumer indebtedness, home equity loans must now be examined along with other forms of consumer installment debt.

Home equity loans are popular for a number of reasons. First, the rise in home values in the 1970s and 1980s created a huge pool of untapped equity. Second, home equity loans are priced as a lower cost alternative to conventional consumer debt. The impact of tax reform is to alter the after-tax cost of borrowing for consumers with a choice of credit sources, either installment debt or home equity loans. But the change in the cost of borrowing only applies to home equity loans taken out for tax-deductible purposes.

Home equity loans are secured loans using the borrower's home equity as collateral. Unlike second mortgages, home equity loans allow borrowers access to funds at different times in various amounts up to their credit limit. The demand and supply for this line of credit expected to rise for two reasons. First, homeowners will want to take advantage of the tax deduction. The Tax Reform Act of 1986 provides for a five year phase-in for the lost deduction of nonmortgage personal interest payments, which probably will increase the tax deduction advantage of home equity loans during the next five years. Second, the interest rate on home equity loans is lower than straight installment credit because home equity loans represents secured credit. Therefore, homeowners with equity in their homes can get a significant interest rate break by taking out a home equity loan as a substitute for conventional borrowing such as personal, car and education loans.

On the supply side, lenders will be more willing to make home equity backed loans, because the collateral is a more secure asset than that for traditional installment loans. The delinquency rates on home equity loans, like other forms of mortgage credit, is likely to be lower than that for unsecured loans. Because the home serving as collateral backing the loan is also a long-term asset, lenders offer longer maturities, with lower interest rates, than typical consumer credit. The result is a lower monthly loan payment.

Therefore, the debt service burden is reduced, in terms of the monthly payment, by changing the form of debt from installment to home equity loans. In addition, the after-tax interest rate is lower compared to traditional installment loans. This impact reemphasizes the narrowness of the ratio of consumer installment debt to personal income as a measure for the influence of credit conditions on consumer behavior.

Home equity loans are particularly threatening to unsecured forms of credit, such as credit cards. For homeowners, interest rates on home equity loans are below credit-card rates. For lenders, the delinquency rate and fraud losses are higher with credit cards than home equity loans. In time, homeowners are expected to view credit card debt and home equity loans as substitutes. In the short-run, some homeowners are likely to take out home equity loans to pay off large, outstanding credit card balances. This substitution immediately reduces the after-tax interest cost on household debt.

STATISTICAL RESULTS

To test the substitution effect, two models were developed. The first model estimated the change in home mortgage debt (FDMORTG) as a function of the change in home values (FDHV) and lagged mortgage rates (RMORTG).

The estimated equation, with t statistics in parenthesis is:

FDMORTG = 57504.9 + 29.2 FDHV - 2441.2 RMORTG

(3.34) (-3.17)

Sample period: March 1978 to June 1986

n = 34 (quarterly data)

[R.sup.2] = 0.80 F (3,30) = 45.96 D.W. = 2.11

Lagrange and LM test fail to reject the null hypothesis of no autocorrelation.

The second model estimated the change of consumer installment debt (FDCIC) as a function of the change in consumer spending (FDC) and consumer credit interest rates (RCIC).

The estimated equation is:

FDCIC = 31.04 + 0.08 FDC - 1.81 RCIC

(2.35) (-2.44)

Sample period: March 1978 to June 1986

n = 34 (quarterly data)

[R.sup.2] = 0.82 F (3,30) = 51.2 D.W. = 2.04

Lagrange and LM tests fail to reject the null hypothesis of no autocorrelation.

If the introduction of home equity loans has the expected substitution effect, actual mortgage debt should rise more than the model forecast, while actual consumer credit should be less than its model forecast. The higher growth rate in mortgages in excess of home values reflects, in part, the influence of home equity loans. Meanwhile, the lower than expected growth in consumer credit reflects a substitution toward home equity loans.

The model results (shown below) confirm these expectations. Beginning in the third quarter of 1986 consumer debt fell sharply below its predicted level. At the same time, mortgage debt rose sharply above its predicted level.

Until the second quarter of 1986, the forecast errors for both equations tended to move in the same direction, reflecting such common factors as consumer confidence and interest rates. But beginning in the second half of 1986 the errors are large and consistently positive compared to earlier periods. This change reflects the substitution effect of home loans on the consumer's choice of credit financing.

The standard errors of the regression are $3.8 billion (Mortgages) and $2.9 billion (Installment Credit). These results again emphasize the offsetting nature of the errors and the large difference between in-sample and out-sample errors.

Estimates of the size of the home equity loan market vary significantly. The latest Federal Reserve release estimates that as of January 6, 1988, home equity loans at commercial banks alone totaled $17 billion. Table 2 below presents three sets of estimates based upon three different methodologies (all estimates are pre-stock market crash).

Size of Home Equity Loan Market
(End of Period Estimates)
Size
Estimator Year (billions of $)
WEFA 1987 $75
1988 $135
SMR 1986 $35
1987 $70
1988 $100
Our Estimates 1986 $54.4
1987 $159.6
The WEFA estimates are based upon simulations of a large macro model. The SMR(1) estimates are those of SMR Research, Inc. and reflect forecasts based upon surveys of individual financial institutions. Our estimates are based upon the equation estimates reported in Table 1.

The Influence of Home Equity Loans
(billions of dollars)
Estimated
Mortgage Installment Home Equity
Period Model Model Loans
Over Forecast Under Forecast Net Flow Stock
1986:3 $27.7 $ 3.0 $24.7 $24.7
1986:4 22.4 - 7.0 29.7 54.4
1987:1 20.3 - 12.9 33.0 87.4
1987:2 23.3 -8.4 31.7 119.1
1987:3 16.1 -2.6 18.7 137.8
1987:4 19.1 -2.7 21.8 159.6
The future growth of home equity loans is likely to follow the increase in home values because the collateral, the homeowner's equity, is directly reflected in the growth of home values. As expectations of future home values rise, homeowners are more likely to assume a home equity loan. For the lender, an increase in the home's value adds to the owner's borrowing capacity.

CONCLUSIONS

The home equity market awakens a number of long-term concerns. First, will borrowers be able to make their loan payments? This question is particularly significant because home equity loan rates are adjustable. As interest rates steadily increase, the payment burden will rise accordingly. Homeowners with both adjustable first mortgages and home equity loans face double jeopardy.

Second, the value of collateral may fluctuate. This issue is particularly relevant given the recent experience in various agriculture and oil-based state economies. In a period of declining property values the loan value of both first and second mortgages may rise relative to the property value. Such a scenario could wipe out all the owner's equity, making default a financial option.

Home equity loans could make the mortgage market riskier. From the supply side the aggressiveness of lenders, as evidenced by "teaser" rates, may lead to overqualifying many borrowers. From the demand side, borrowers may ignore the risk of significant future interest rate increases or economic downturns. In the end, home equity loans could make the home mortgage market more volatile.(2)

This paper has focused on the substitution of home equity loans for consumer installment credit. Alternatively, homeowners may simply add to their total debt burden by using home equity loans to finance further purchases. In the long-term, this may create an overleveraged consumer.

FOOTNOTES

(1) Second Mortgages and Home Equity Loans: Growth, Strategies & Competition. SMR Research Corporation. February, 1987.

(2) In addition, distributional changes occur in consumer credit markets. For a review of these changes, see "Consumer Installment Credit in the 1970s", by William Dunkelberg, et. al., 1980, (unpublished manuscript, Purdue University).

*John Silvia is Vice President and Economist, Kemper Financial Services, Inc., Chicago, IL. Barry Whall is an Economic Analyst, Chrysler Corp. Detroit, MI. This paper is adapted from one presented at the 29th Annual Meeting of The National Association of Business Economist, October 5-7, 1987, New Orleans, LA. Special thanks are due to Van Bussmann, Peggy Ryan, Gerard Francovic and Steve Hotopp for research support.

COPYRIGHT 1989 The National Association for Business Economists
COPYRIGHT 2004 Gale Group

Author Info:

Authored by: John E. Silvia

 
30 Most Recent Articles :
Affiliate Programs That Make You Money by Ratliff J

This information may be helpful for everyone, regardless of how long you have been in the affiliate business, or even if you are just getting started. First, a good affiliate program can be hard to come by. It needs to offer decent commissions, accurately track sales, and most importantly, pay[ Read Article]

Your Content for Nothing and Your Clicks for Free by David Westbrook

Your Content for Nothing and Your Clicks for Free ? 2005, David Westbrook You have permission to publish this article electronically or in print, free of charge, as long as you leave the article title, author name, body and resource box in tact with the links made active This article has[ Read Article]

The Truth about Google?s Adsense affiliate program. by Shawn Ventura

The truth about Google?s Adsense program is that it is amazing. It?s the greatest affiliate program ever invented. There is no affiliate program that even comes close. If you are not using Google?s Adsense, you?re truly missing out on a great opportunity. I?ve tried several other affiliate program[ Read Article]

How to make money with Affiliate Programs - The Sensible Way by Xavier Nelson

Every day, thousands of would-be marketers scour the internet looking for any and every affiliate program, sign up, sit back and wait for the money to pour in and get frustrated just as fast when the bank balance still shows a big, fat ZERO! There are tons of guru's floating around and even [ Read Article]

Affiliate Program Intro by Shanon Lewis

What is an affiliate program? Everyone who surfs the web has come across affiliate programs. You may have seen a banner on a website that says, ?click here?, and once you do, you get access to whatever?s being promoted. Or you could click on a link in an email you?ve received. You?re using someone[ Read Article]

Poor Birdy by Robert Kennedy

I want to tell you a true story that is actually sad, but perhaps there is a learning lesson for all of us here. Today I woke up ready to get busy. My basic routine is shower, shave and Java. I had a few meetings this morning so I had to stop at a local 7-11 for my java (coffee). I pull into the p[ Read Article]

Loving Without Losing Yourself by Allie Ochs

Loving Without Losing Yourself! You are in love and this time it is different. You are prepared to do anything to make it last. To prevent this ship from sinking you work hard to steer this relationship into a safe harbor. In the process you lose yourself and your romantic relationship becomes [ Read Article]

Nicely Designed Pillows As Gifts by Glenn Prialde

Many of us are probably squeezing out our brains to the limit just for a single purpose, to think of what to give especially when it?s Christmas or just a simple birthday present. It?s always nice to give the jewelries, toys, clothes and shoes as we all had been used to of what to give. But haven?[ Read Article]

All About Paintballs by Tim Bach

All About Paintballs Paintballs are gelatin capsules filled with a water-soluble marking dye. The dye inside is non-toxic, meaning that if you swallow it, it will not hurt you. However, the taste is not very pleasant. Paintballs are manufactured by many different companies. As with most thin[ Read Article]

Alarm Systems: Not Just For The Wealthy Anymore! by Matthew Francis

Over the last 22 years that I have been involved in the security alarm industry, I have seen quite an evolution. Changes have not only taken place in what type of equipment is available, but also in how the consumer buys and use?s the equipment. When I first started in the business, alarms wher[ Read Article]

Can you get fuller breasts from natural breast enhancement supplements? by Danna Schneider

There have, in very recent years, been a flood of breast enhancement and breast enlargement supplements put on the market. All of them make the same claims of being an effective and safe alternative to breast augmentation surgery. For many women, small or unattractively shaped and sized breasts are [ Read Article]

keeping New Year's Resolutions by John Satterfield CH

Success With New Year?s Resolutions John Satterfield is a certified hypnotherapist practicing in Mountain View. He specializes in helping clients have success with stopping smoking and losing weight You can reach him by telephone at 870-269-6811 Also get his free report ?Never Be Lied To Again?[ Read Article]

Melanin: Aging of the Skin and Skin Cancer

"Ultraviolet (UV) radiation is responsible for 90% of the visible signs of aging on the skin of whites," says Dr. Michael J. Martin, former Assistant Clinical Professor in the Dept. of Epidemiology and Biostatistics at University of California, San Francisco. Blacks' skin, however, ages much sl[ Read Article]

Sunlight for Your Life

All life on the planet and everything in nature is dependent on the sun. Without the sun, there would be no life on the planet. All life is dependent on the sun. Plants convert the sunlight into energy, and all animals need plant life or other animals in order to live. All life in nature is depend[ Read Article]

?Super Verbs? Really Move Your Copy by Karon Thackston

By Karon Thackston ? 2004 http://www.learn-copywriting.com Run or hustle? Eat or devour? Move or scurry? You can boost the power of your copy by boosting the quality of verbs you use. Verbs show action, and the way you describe that action can have a dramatic bearing on your readers. Why would[ Read Article]

How To Get Attention, or: 'As You Read This, You Feel an Irresistible Urge to Go On Reading!' by Kai Virihaur

We all want attention. As children we crave the attention of our parents. Later in life, we want to be seen and noticed by friends and lovers. And when running most any type of business, we must attract the attention of our potential customers. But how do you get somebody's undivided attention?[ Read Article]

Hitching a Ride on Current Events by Paul J. Krupin

You have permission to publish this article electronically or in print, free of charge, as long as the bylines are included. A courtesy copy of your publication would be appreciated - send to Hitching a Ride on Current Events by Paul J. Krupin Current events do present opportunities for me[ Read Article]

How to "Disguise" Your Sales Letters Online by Andrew Clacy

How to ?Disguise? Your Sales Letters Online The Internet is known as the ?Information Super Highway? and that?s a term that every Internetmarketer should know by heart. Why? People log onto the Internet to get information,not to be sold. Many people online are turned off at anything thatresemb[ Read Article]

Your Article is Being Used Without a Resource Box - What Can You Do? by Francisco Aloy

Your Article is Being Used Without a Resource Box - What can you do? Sooner or later, no matter how much you hate it, some Webmaster is going to use your article and won't include your resource box. Another common practice is that of replacing your HTML link with a text link. Funny thing,when [ Read Article]

A simple 7-step checklist to test your ads by Andre Clacy www.explosivecopycourse.com

Imagine if you had in your hand a simple, bullet-proof, 7-step checklist to test your ads and sales letters. Well, here?s a simple 7-step checklist that Joe uses every time he writes copy. Every marketing piece of his that passes the test has gone on to generate sales. In one of his les[ Read Article]

How Does Spellchecker make you Lazy? by David Parton

It's a crime what laziness can do. That's the downside of automation and software tools. People get lazy. Don't get me wrong, I love technology and I depend on Spell-checking software to help with my writing. It finds the typos but it does not find all the spelling mistakes.It does not find the[ Read Article]

How To Test Your Headlines Without Spending A Fortune In Advertising Fees by Thomas A. Hilton, Jr.

So, you've spent all this time on creating your product and you've read all the advice from every marketing expert on the internet. You've discovered one common ground among them all. And they all do agree on this one thing. Testing the headlines is critical. They all say that it's the absol[ Read Article]

How To Write Powerful Headlines by Al Martinovic

How To Write Powerful Headlines By Al Martinovic I want to tell you how I go about writing headlines. I like to keep swap files of headlines around for future use. And how I go about doing it goes something like this... I'll find a headline I like, wherever it may be, and then I don't copy[ Read Article]

Public Relations?A Free Lunch? by Claire Cunningham

Seems like everyone is looking for the proverbial free lunch these days, particularly when it comes to marketing communications. Well, I hate to burst anyone's bubble, but there's no such thing. However, there are ways to stretch your budget and marketing public relations (PR) is one of them. [ Read Article]

Instant Messaging ? A Powerful Communication Tool for Your Business by Cavyl Stewart

Many people do it so innocently that it?s hard to believe the dangers that are lurking. Spammers, pfishers, hackers, predators ? they?re all poised to wreak havoc on you, your employees and your business contacts. Yet many people don?t even realize that these dangers exist because, after all, th[ Read Article]

International Telephone Calling Tips by Raymond Klesc

International Telephone Calling Tips By Raymond Klesc Global Value Connect http://www.globalvalueconnect.com If your business requires overseas communications with suppliers or customers; or if you have a loved one living or traveling abroad; you know that the cost for overseas calls can com[ Read Article]

How to Improve Your Word Power! by Royane Real

If you want to be a great communicator, do you need to have a great vocabulary? You might be surprised to learn that a really big vocabulary is not necessary in order to express yourself clearly and to move others with your words. Some of the most dramatic messages that have ever been utter[ Read Article]

E-Book Writing Formats: How to Make the Words Flow by Dina Giolitto, Wordfeeder.com

Nervous about writing your first e-book? Never fear. E-books are written in a conversational, informative style that's easy for the reader to understand, and easy for you to imitate as you write them. Whether it's ten pages about Smart Finances, 50 pages on How to Care for Your Cat or 250 pages co[ Read Article]

How To Breeze Through The Security Checkpoint At Airports by Jamie Madison

Permission is freely granted to use this article so long as our resource box remains at the end of this article with all links live. Air travel is such a common method of transportation today, we sometimes forget the practical tips to help us enjoy a flight. The following tips will help you red[ Read Article]

The Pyramids of Giza by Steven N. Ng

The most famous Egyptian pyramids to be built are the Great Pyramids of Giza, located in the outskirts of present-day Cairo. There are over 100 Egyptian pyramids of various sizes, and over 50 more in neighboring Sudan. However, the three Great Pyramids of Giza earn their fame by being the largest [ Read Article]

 

 

Partners : Free Online Games -

Copyright © articles4free.net  2008. All Rights Reserved.



darowizny Pozycjonowanie naturalna pielęgnacja Pozycjonowanie strony paffoni

free lyrics - real estate agency - Warum immer ich? - Jokes - Myspace proxy - kanutouren - Download Mp3 Songs - Best lyrics - Electro parts one click away - brass castings - embroidered patches - Tahitian Noni Juice - Pax - free holdem - saliva drug test


Forex Forex Online Forex najtansze domeny sprzęt agd